Advice for Non-Scientists

Advice for non-scientists about living and working with scientists, engineers and doctors from a lady who should know. If you have a question for Mrs. Newton, please e-mail her at askmrsnewton@gmail.com. She will try to respond to as many questions as she can. Be sure to indicate how you want your query signed should it appear in print. Examples are Lola Labtech or Spliceless in Seattle.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Refrigerator Microbes

Dear Mrs. Newton,

I met my roommate, Laurie, at her workplace, a hospital lab, because we planned to go straight to the movies from her downtown location. She asked if I could wait a few minutes because she was finishing up a project. I said "no problem" and she offered me a soda while I waited. I accepted. She walked to a refrigerator down from her lab bench, opened the door and selected a Diet Coke. Before the door closed behind her, I got an eye full of the other stuff in the refrigerator. EeeeeeeeUuuuuuu. I made a production of yanking the ring off the Coke, but I wasn't going to drink from that can if my life depended on it. I thought about wiping the top off after running water over it in sink near Laurie's workstation, but realized immediately that wiping wasn't gonna do it for me, and who knows what else had been in that sink. Yuck!As we were leaving, I slipped the full can of pop into the trash. How can she eat and drink stuff that has been sitting in the same space as her specimens?

Grossed Out Girlfriend

 

Dear Grossed Out,

Okay, perhaps keeping food in the lab fridge isn't the best of solutions for the afternoon munchies, but the point is your roomy knows about the invisible world of germs. She understands how they move around and how to keep them from getting somewhere where they are not wanted. She probably laughs secretly at you when you make a big production of washing your hands in the restroom, only to grasp the door handle on your way out and rub your face a second later. The coke is okay. But knowing something is clean in your rational mind isn't going to do anything about your sensibilities. You aren't going to be able to erase the picture of those little specimen bottles or Petri dishes, so don't feel guilty about wasting the Coke. Scientists have foibles too. I know one who eats the food on his plate sequentially – all the peas, then all the potatoes, then all the meat. And another who eats his hamburgers in a circle. If she starts storing strange biological samples picked up from her hiking trip in the refrigerator you share at home, put your foot down. Roommates have to compromise about the spaces they share. Tell her to buy one of those little bar units.



Introductions Among Scientists

Dear Mrs. Newton,

I have a public relations job at a new company. It is my first experience working for a technical company. Last Friday night, before leaving work, I attended the monthly beer bash in the cafeteria. I joined a group which contained one of the few people in the R & D department I have met so far. He and I were in the same orientation put on by human resources to review the company's benefits package. As I juggled my Coors Lite, he introduced himself to the other scientists in the circle by telling them where he went to school and where he did his post-doctoral studies. He mentioned that he had he worked in the laboratory of a Professor Herman Schultz. Up to that point, the other guys in the circle were fidgeting or scanning the crowd for prospective dates. Suddenly, my new acquaintance had everybody's attention. You would have thought he was about to read out the lottery numbers for the Mega-Millions jackpot. When I am introducing myself to scientists should I mention the names of my journalism professors? I studied with some real heavyweights.

Mystified Margaret

Dear Margaret,

Just as you don't know who Dr. Schultz is, your scientific colleagues are unlikely to recognize the names of your accomplished professors. We live in a very specialized world. However, within a particular specialization, the stars are known to all. Your colleague was informing the other scientists that he had studied with an important professor, someone who had made significant contributions to their field. The other people in the circle had probably heard Dr. Schultz give a paper at an important meeting or, at the very least, read some of his published work. In the scientific disciplines, mentioning key professors and mentors is an efficient way of letting others know about your specialized knowledge and training. It is helpful shorthand. I would not try copying this behavior, because, in your case, with your background in a completely different sphere, it would not serve the same purpose. I suggest you Google Professor Schultz and learn why he is famous. Don't be frustrated if you can't figure it out right off the bat. Oftentimes, profound scientific contributions are subtle or even obscure to lay people. Ask your new friend to translate for you. Chances are, he'll be happy to oblige and a bit flattered as well.


Friday, July 10, 2009

Thoughtful Gift Rejected

Dear Mrs. Newton,

My boyfriend, Jeff, is in med school and with all that studying, he has gained a few pounds. I have modified my shopping list and changed my meal preparation habits to accommodate his need to shed the weight. The other day, I was in the herbal section of the grocery store, and I saw another way I could help. I bought a bottle of Green Tea Extract which many of my friends use in their weight loss struggles. I made him a present of the bottle two weeks ago. This morning, I ran out of toothpaste, and, when I opened his side of the medicine cabinet to borrow his tube, I spotted the gift bottle. The seal was still intact. Why hasn't he taken the pills?

Tea-ed Off


Dear TO,

Your boyfriend is preparing for a career in medicine, and doctors take drugs very seriously. Drugs are regulated and are subjected to rigorous testing before they are approved for use in humans and they continue to be monitored after market introduction so that data are gathered on any side effects that occur. Manufacturers may not claim any benefits for a product that have not been proven in properly designed and executed clinical tests. These tests not only demonstrate the efficacy of a drug, but delineate how the drug works, and determine the dose and regimen that will produce the desired result and avoid side effects. By contrast, nutritionals often have been used for centuries and their usefulness to treat a particular ailment is supported by folk wisdom. Today, we know much more about the chemical structure and activity of nutritional supplements like the green tea catechins, but the scientific testing to prove their efficacy and detail their optimum use as a medicine has not been done or has been shown in studies that are too small to be definitive. Evidence that green tea extracts play a role in fat oxidation (fat burning) and thermogenesis (heat production in the body) is tantalizing, but there is no proof that any of these substances can be used therapeutically to achieve weight loss. Your boyfriend might be more interested in a product backed by a large body of clinical studies. ALLI (Orlistat), a weight loss aid made by GlaxoSmithKline, is an example. Doctors and other people with scientific training do not believe product claims unless that are backed up by tests. Don't be too hard on Jeff, if the little bottle gets shoved to the back of the medicine cabinet.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Presentation to R & D Management Falls Flat

Dear Mrs. Newton,

I gave what I thought was a first class presentation on our company's new hiring policies to our R & D management yesterday. Toward the end of my talk, I made a little joke about the silly habit scientist candidates have of mentioning with whom they studied while at university during job interviews. This morning my inbox is full of snide e-mails. What's the big deal?

Lars in Human Resources

Dear Lars,

Scientists know who the stars are in their field of concentration. When a candidate mentions in passing that he studied with Dr. Maximus Jones at Northwestern University, you might not get it, but the head of your R & D division will know that Dr. Jones is a genius in nanotechnology, and weigh in his hiring decision that this young scientist was mentored by a giant. Students compete mightily for spots in the laboratories of leading researchers. Your joke wasn't funny because it trivialized something the people listening to you value on their co-worker's CVs ( the scientific version of resumes), and worked hard to accomplish themselves. Swallow your pride, thank the people who e-mailed you and tell them you have learned a valuable lesson you will put to good use in technical recruiting.