Advice for Non-Scientists

Advice for non-scientists about living and working with scientists, engineers and doctors from a lady who should know. If you have a question for Mrs. Newton, please e-mail her at askmrsnewton@gmail.com. She will try to respond to as many questions as she can. Be sure to indicate how you want your query signed should it appear in print. Examples are Lola Labtech or Spliceless in Seattle.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Presentation to R & D Management Falls Flat

Dear Mrs. Newton,

I gave what I thought was a first class presentation on our company's new hiring policies to our R & D management yesterday. Toward the end of my talk, I made a little joke about the silly habit scientist candidates have of mentioning with whom they studied while at university during job interviews. This morning my inbox is full of snide e-mails. What's the big deal?

Lars in Human Resources

Dear Lars,

Scientists know who the stars are in their field of concentration. When a candidate mentions in passing that he studied with Dr. Maximus Jones at Northwestern University, you might not get it, but the head of your R & D division will know that Dr. Jones is a genius in nanotechnology, and weigh in his hiring decision that this young scientist was mentored by a giant. Students compete mightily for spots in the laboratories of leading researchers. Your joke wasn't funny because it trivialized something the people listening to you value on their co-worker's CVs ( the scientific version of resumes), and worked hard to accomplish themselves. Swallow your pride, thank the people who e-mailed you and tell them you have learned a valuable lesson you will put to good use in technical recruiting.



No comments:

Post a Comment